| Age | Distilled 1958. Bottling date unknown |
| Strength | 75° proof |
| Tasting date | Not recorded |
| Comments | Bottled by Gordon & McPhail |
| Members' comments | "Fine example of western isle peaty malt. Perhaps a little peatier than the 12 year old", "A very good example of old, well-matured whisky", "A pleasant Talisker, but it doesn't come to the heights a 1958 Talisker should:, "Good quality malt, with flowery overtones of Skye heater", "Very good", "Pleasant, rounded, smokey whisky. Not overpowering", "Certainly not the usual Talisker. Full bodied". |
| Points allotted | 7.2 |
27/8/94